Questioning Sustainable Development

Introduction

Introduction

Sustainable development (SD) became popular after Bruntland Commission Report was published in the form of a book – Our Common Future in 1987. The concept articulated that development can be sustainable if it provides adequate supply of natural resources for the needs of present generation and leaves enough for the future ones. This concept caught imagination of people on the opposite sides of the conservation-development debate as well as the fence-sitters. Developmentalists and governments globally pushed for economic growth as the legitimate instrument of human development and welfare, while environmentalists thought that they would extract concessions from them using SD as a new promotional tool for the environmental protection. The twin idea of the SD paradigm was: the ‘needs’ of poor nations must be given priority at all costs and ‘environmental resource limits’ must be recognized to maintain an inter-generational equity. In principle, it was a robust initiative, but in practice, we have witnessed emergence of new economic order, pushing further the age-old economic agenda instead of the SD model. China and India emerged as new economic leaders post SD, which only led to more serious environmental conflicts with no agreement in sight. Therefore, as an academic inquiry it is necessary to find out if SD is a business as usual model or is there credible evidence of its positive impact. Additionally, any alternate idea with more and/or better promise will be explored. Some of the questions that may be asked include:

Where and how did it all begin? Has SD delivered the promise it held for the ‘poor’ and the ‘developed’ nations? Is SD possible or is it an oxymoron? Is there a place for other species and systems than humans in the scheme of SD? Are the traditional bio-resource/bio-energy driven societies relevant to the framework of SD? Can technology alone be the agent of change? Can ‘win-win ecology’ win? 

Objectives

The main objectives of the module are to provide students with an understanding that will allow them to:

  • Recognize the impact of economic activity on the natural resources by studying and analyzing contemporary and contrarian theories on sustainable development.
  • Understand the current and projected use of natural resources to establish their criticality in human survival and future.
  • Critically analyze the role of various technological, institutional and socio-political instruments in success or failure of achieving sustainable development.
  • Relate to the need for sustainable development in our daily lives and search for new paradigms of sustainability.

The module will emphasize on case studies and promote critical and analytical discussions among students on the idea of ‘sustainability’ in a world that is dominated by ‘prodigious consumerism’. The module will engage students to seek answers to the ‘sustainability’ of sustainable development itself. Going beyond boundaries of natural and social sciences, technology and politics, the module conforms to the pedagogical structure within USP.

Course Content

Course Content

The main topics to be covered in this module are:

Unit 1: Introduction (2 Weeks)

This unit introduces the context of sustainable development with reference to the United Nations Conference on the Human Environment (Stockholm Conference) and in the background of the nature of earth’s surface and human operations in the critical zone and establishes linkages between ascent of human species and the global change.

Unit 2: Economics, Environment and Development (2 Weeks)

This unit discusses various economic models within the framework of economic behaviour of nations, governments, people and industry in pursuit of human welfare and development. It explores the linkages between economic activity and environmental degradation by studying the life cycle of raw materials, use of energy in transforming them into finished products and bi-products that escape the anticipated ‘circular flows’ and pose serious problems to natural environment. Pollution and climate change are the two well known examples linked to traditional economic models.

Unit 3: Critical Natural Resources(4 Weeks)

This unit provides a multi-disciplinary understanding of criticality of natural resources in terms of their current global status, exploitation and future projections for human use. Importance of land and water resources to sustain agriculture needs, climate resources and impact of climate change on productivity of natural and managed ecosystems linked to human survival will be discussed. The role of various international, regional and national protocols including United Nations Framework on Climate Change, Kyoto Protocol, Copenhagen and Cancun Declarations and impediments to consensus will be debated. Key instruments such as environmental impact assessment, strategic environmental assessment and carrying capacity based developmental planning in achieving sustainable development will be critically examined.

Unit 4: Businesses, Livelihoods and Our Common Future (5 Weeks)

This unit looks at the modern approaches to solving the problem of environmental degradation through legal, political economic and technology options. The unit examines human poverty in the context of environmental degradation and disproportionate use of natural resources and the need for their rational global distribution and access. Models to address a just system of resource distribution through corporate social responsibility, social entrepreneurship, and development of green businesses will be examined. The unit will explore case studies for sustainable life styles in green urban centres including that of Singapore

Lecture Schedule

Lecture Schedule

Instruction Seminar No. Date Seminar Title
Week 1 Seminar 1  14.01.2019 Introduction: Where & How did it all Begin
Seminar 2  16.01.2019 Why Question Sustainable Development?
Week 2  Seminar 3  21.01.2019 Earth's Surface as Critical Zone
Seminar 4  23.01.2019 Humans & Changing Face of the Earth
Week 3 Seminar 5  28.01.2019 Anthropocene and the Global Change
Seminar 6  30.01.2019 Beginnings of Our Common Future
Week 4 Chinese New Year Eve  04.02.2019 No Class
Holiday  06.02.2019 Chinese New Year
Week 5 Seminar 7  11.02.2019 Economic Models & Human Welfare
Seminar 8  13.02.2019 Energy & Economic Development
Week 6 Seminar 9  18.02.2019 Ecological/Environmental Economics
Seminar 10  20.02.2019 Economic Growth & Development Read & Discuss Papers [The Dependence Effect by JK Galbraith] & The Non Sequitur of the "Dependence Effect" by Friedrick A. Hayek]
Mid-Semester Break
Mid-Semester Break
Week 7  Seminar 11  04.03.2019 Mid term Test: MCQ based
Seminar 12  06.03.2019 Economic Evaluation of Natural Capital: Means & Methods
Week 8 Seminar 13  11.03.2019 Land, Soil & Water: Status, Demand, Supply & Management
Seminar 14  13.03.2019 Economic Value of the Natural World Read & Discuss Paper – Economic Reasons for Conserving Wild Nature by Andrew Balmford et al. 2002 & Economics of Biodiversity: Lives & Lifestyles by Swaney & Olson, 1992.
Week 9 Seminar 15  18.03.2019 Carrying Capacity & Resource Limits: Environment Impact Assessment & Development Projects
Seminar 16  20.03.2019 A World Without Water (Environmental Catastrophe Documentary)
Week 10 Seminar 17  25.03.2019 Poverty & Natural Resource Utilization
Seminar 18  27.03.2019 Towards Sustainability Read & Discuss Papers – Reconciling Environment and Development in the Clean Development Mechanism by Kerr et al., 2006 & Is the Clean Development Mechanism Sustainable? Some Critical Aspects by Voigt, 2008.
Week 11 Seminar 19  01.04.2019 Urban Life Styles, Green Cities & Green Businesses
Seminar 20  03.04.2019 Geo-politics & Sustainable Development*
Week 12 Seminar 21  08.04.2019 Business Ethics & Social Responsibility [Read & Discuss Paper – Pinto Madness by Mark Dowie].
Seminar 22  10.04.2019 Sustainable Development: Summing Up. [Read & Discuss Paper – Squaring the circle? Some thoughts on the idea of sustainable development by Robinson, 2004.
Sustainable Living: Pandit, 2017
Week 13  Seminar 23  15.04.2019 Students' Presentations
 Seminar 24  17.04.2019 Students' Presentations

Organization

Organization

The instruction model organized for 35 students involves classroom teaching (seminar style) of two hours duration twice a week on the subject. Lectures in the beginning of term will highlight the key concepts and principles of earth’s surface processes and resources, and the subsequent lectures will examine the criticality of these resources to human survival and finally try to comprehend the role of humans in changing some of the natural cycles. A number of case studies will be discussed in the global, regional and local context. We will make an endeavour, throughput the semester, to question the positions on both sides of the sustainable development (SD) debate. After the seminars are completed there will be classroom interactions and presentations by individual students to present and discuss their take on various facets of SD.

Students would be provided with lecture notes on upcoming seminar topics prior to classroom interaction. These will be posted on the IVLE website.

Assessment Schedule

Assessment Schedule

Mid-Term Exam

The students are required to complete a mid-term assignment, which may include an MCQ test on the topics covered in the class.

Individual Presentations

Each student will select a topic of his/her choice and prepare a power point presentation. This exercise is aimed at developing independent thinking and conceptualization of a theme, researching material for presentations, developing oratorial skills and managing the audiences’ questions and points of view. The students will be assessed for the succinctness and clarity; in particular, the captivating title of the talk, clear methodology, content, message and conclusions. Each presentation would be of 7-10 minute duration.

Essay/Paper

Each student is required to write an essay on a topic given by the instructor. The essay/paper should not be more than 1000 words (minimum 800 words). The submission shall contain answers to specific questions given by the instructor in the context of published work on the subject of Sustainable Development.

Group Project

As a part of training in carrying out independent studies the students are required to choose a topic of choice relevant to SD debate or future solutions. To foster an attitude of working in a group, the students would form groups of 3-4 individuals and prepare a written (minimum 2500 and maximum of 3000 words) report/paper. The submission shall be organized into chapters/sub-headings elucidating the students’ grasp of the problem, sources and methodology of materials collected, analysis of the material and the group’s own views in the context of existing published literature. Each group will have to clearly spell out the participant student’s contribution to the effort.

Final Examination

The final examination will be held on on 29 April 2019, 9am

Assessment Schedule

CA Components
%
Deadlines
1.
Mid – Term Exam (quizzes, multiple choice written tests)
15%
 4th March, 2019
2.
Essay/Papers (Assignment):
20%
 3rd April, 2019
3.
Individual Presentations: Presentation to be made by individual scholars on any topic of his/her choice including on the field visits.
15%
 15th & 17th April, 2019
4.
Group Project: (Assignment)A group of maximum 4 scholars submitting a joint paper/ dissertation on a given topic.
20%
 TBA
Total for CA Components:
70%
Total for Final Examinations:
30%
 29 April 2019, 5pm
Total Assessment:
100%
Scroll to Top